Call Us: (852)37026770  |  Email Us: [email protected]

What Are Structured Interviews and Why Ought to You Use Them?

Kelly Lee
Digital Content Specialist


Interviews are a essential a part of your hiring course of, and but, figuring out whether or not a candidate is true for a task could be difficult. Can a one-hour interview actually let you know every part it’s essential know earlier than hiring a brand new workforce member? 

Because of this alone, many recruiting groups contain greater than only a hiring supervisor or expertise acquisition chief within the interview course of. For instance, when hiring for a buyer success position, you’ll doubtless embrace a Senior Buyer Success Supervisor and Buyer Success Technician in interviews to allow them to ask pertinent questions and get to know candidates. 

Which questions will these workforce members ask, and the way will they assess whether or not a candidate is the appropriate match? Guaranteeing everybody concerned within the hiring course of is aligned is essential to working profitable, fruitful interviews, and but, many groups battle with retaining interviews aligned with hiring objectives and aims.

That is the place structured interviews are available. They can assist enhance and streamline your hiring course of whereas eliminating bias in your interviews. Let’s dive in!

What’s a structured interview?

A structured interview (additionally known as a ‘structured job interview’) is a technique of evaluation that measures how competent a candidate is for a task by asking all candidates the identical set of questions and evaluating them towards the identical standards. 

Structured interviews require a hiring workforce to develop a clearly outlined goal for every interview, together with a selected set of questions for every interviewer to ask. This features a rubric or scorecard of some type that helps interviewers assess solutions to every query. This implies: 

  • All candidates are requested the identical predetermined questions, in the identical order
  • All candidates’ responses are evaluated utilizing the identical standards or scale 

Why are structured interviews higher?

Conducting job interviews can appear fairly simple. 

Candidates come into your expertise pipeline for an open position, you select those you’d wish to interview, and also you ask them a sequence of questions. Primarily based on their responses and your expertise, you progress ahead with the candidate you suppose most closely fits the position. 

Upon second look, nevertheless, you’ll discover {that a} temporary interview and a ‘intestine feeling’ aren’t sufficient to make the simplest hiring selections—particularly when different stakeholders or influencers are concerned. 

Structured interviews allow you to rent the appropriate candidate

Hiring the unsuitable candidate could be expensive. Research have proven that, on common, a nasty rent can price an organization upwards of $15,000. In the meantime, 74% of managers say they’ve employed the unsuitable individual for a place at one time or one other. 

That will help you select the appropriate candidates, a structured interview course of is vital. In accordance with analysis, structured interviews are twice as efficient at predicting job efficiency as unstructured ones and can assist eradicate or cut back affirmation bias in your hiring. 

The benefits to utilizing structured interviews

Many recruiters contemplate structured interviews to be simpler, as they’re primarily based on a clearly outlined position and its core aims—a hiring workforce makes use of a rubric and deliberate set of questions that foster data-driven hiring selections. 

Let’s check out the important thing benefits of utilizing structured interviews. 

  • Higher predict job efficiency — as we talked about above, research have proven that structured interviews can assist you higher predict a candidate’s job efficiency
  • Get rid of affirmation bias — all candidates are requested the identical questions and are assessed utilizing the identical rubric, serving to guarantee your hiring is equitable whereas reducing the chance of affirmation bias 
  • Information-driven vs emotional hiring — as candidates are assessed primarily based on standardized standards fairly than ‘intestine intuition’ or feeling, hiring groups could make extra data-driven hiring selections 
  • Optimize interview time — having a structured interview framework in place can assist managers and stakeholders optimize the time they’ve with every candidate

Advantages of leveraging structured interviews for candidates and employers

The intention behind structured interviews is to assist recruiters and hiring groups make goal hiring selections, which in the end advantages each the candidate who will get employed and the group. 

Structured interviews profit candidates in a couple of key methods: 

  • Candidates are assessed primarily based on expertise and qualities as they relate to the core aims of the position (versus private choice)
  • All candidates are requested the identical questions and assessed utilizing the identical standards, making the hiring course of extra intentional and truthful
  • Interviews are extra deliberate and outcome-oriented, which maximizes the time a candidate has with a hiring supervisor 

Structured interviews profit employers as they:

  • Assist to cut back unconscious bias and/or affirmation bias in interviews
  • Create a extra deliberate, intentional, and standardized course of for interviews that helps hiring groups select the appropriate candidates
  • Permits hiring groups to leverage their time with candidates extra productively by asking the appropriate questions 

The three sorts of interviews recruiters leverage

In the present day, job interviews are carried out in quite a few alternative ways and might embrace a number of steps and touchpoints. Take into consideration digital, in-person, and phone interviews—together with one-on-one, panel, or group interviews. Whichever format you select, a job interview could be structured in one in all 3 ways: 

  • Unstructured
  • Semi-structured
  • Structured 

What are the core variations between these three interview sorts, and why or when must you leverage every? We’ll begin with structured vs unstructured interviews. 

Structured vs unstructured interviews

In a structured interview, the interviewer asks a selected sequence of predetermined questions. These questions are deliberate prematurely so that every candidate is requested the identical set of questions in the identical order. 

You might also see or hear structured interviews known as ‘deliberate interviews’ or ‘formalized interviews’ however the goal is similar: setting a standardized course of for interviewing candidates. 

Structured interviews are your most secure wager when conducting extra equitable and inclusive interviews, as you’re required to stay to a prescribed course of that assesses candidates pretty, not subjectively. 

In an unstructured interview, an interviewer leads the dialogue and asks questions with none preparation. So, questions are usually not predetermined and there’s no path or course of put in place beforehand. In different phrases, the interviewer flies by the seat of their pants!

In any other case referred to as casual interviews or a non-directive interview, unstructured interviews have recruiters or hiring managers asking random units or sorts of questions—this implies every candidate is requested completely different questions and could also be given completely different situations to reply to (and there’s no set order or prescribed rubric). 

Structured vs semi-structured interviews

We’ve gone over structured and unstructured interviews; now, we have to reply the query, “what are semi-structured interviews?”

Consider semi-structured interviews as a hybrid interview; the interviewer doesn’t ask a formalized set of questions however as a substitute sticks to a short listing of predetermined speaking factors whereas letting the remainder of the dialog stream naturally. For instance, they might ask the candidate extra open-ended questions or enable the candidate to ‘lead’ the interview by talking about their experiences and dealing type or asking the interviewer in regards to the firm tradition. 

When you’ll nonetheless need to keep on with the identical primary construction for every candidate’s interview course of, there are some circumstances the place it is sensible to deviate just a little extra by utilizing a semi-structured interview:

  1. You’re courting a really passive candidate. Some candidates are very passive and received’t be able to enter into your recruitment course of immediately. On this case, you might want so as to add an additional introductory cellphone name or espresso assembly (or a number of of every) to heat the candidate as much as the concept of creating a transfer.
  2. You’re about to lose a top-choice candidate. Reverse of the passive candidate is the candidate who’s in very excessive demand and is bordering on accepting a suggestion elsewhere. There can be instances once you’ll want to hurry up your recruitment course of to make fast selections for top-choice candidates earlier than they’re now not accessible.
  3. Casual gatherings are a part of your course of. When an off-the-cuff gathering is a part of your interview course of, it doesn’t (and mustn’t) must be structured. This is a chance in your staff and candidates to get to know each other in a extra relaxed setting. Let the dialog occur organically, very like it will over a traditional workforce lunch or outing.
  4. Your questions are revealed. When some candidates can put together their responses and others can’t, they’re now not on a stage taking part in area. Assessment Glassdoor often to see in case your behavioral interview questions and work pattern exams have been revealed. If they’ve, contemplate whether or not you need to change them for the rest of your candidates.

Why you need to use a structured interview framework

If structured interviews are simpler, why don’t all hiring groups use them when recruiting and nurturing candidates? Properly, it might have loads to do with consolation. 

Analysis has proven that, basically, interviewers tend to think they’re nice at interviewing, so few will replace their expertise or observe new methods of conducting interviews. However interviewing can shortly turn into an off-the-cuff, virtually informal course of when you’re tasked with interviewing candidates typically or at scale. This will result in ineffective interviews that hinder hiring groups from correctly assessing candidates—and might result in the ‘interview impact.’ 

In brief, the ‘interview effect’ happens when an interviewer unintentionally influences the interviewee. For instance, an interviewer’s physique language and responses can affect how a candidate solutions questions. Given interviews are social interactions, an informal or unstructured method can bias folks’s responses or behaviors in an interview. 

On this sense, having a structured interview framework in place allows your hiring workforce to conduct simpler, unbiased interviews. There are advantages for each organizations and candidates.

How profitable is your recruitment mannequin, actually?

In the present day’s fashionable recruiter has loads to juggle earlier than you possibly can even rent the appropriate candidates, not to mention supply them. Efficiently sourcing, partaking, and hiring expertise to develop your group should begin together with your recruitment mannequin—how efficient is yours? Take our temporary evaluation to seek out out how one can take your expertise acquisition technique to new heights.

CTA image for a talent assessment test


Your Recruitment Partner in Hong Kong

Are you
looking for a CHANGE?

Are you